Impact Windows vs. Impact Screens: Which is Right for Your Florida Home?

Protecting Your Home Starts With the Right Barrier

Florida homeowners know that hurricane protection isn’t just a luxury—it’s a necessity. With violent winds, flying debris, and sudden pressure changes, the right protective solution can mean the difference between minimal damage and major devastation.

Among the most talked-about options are impact windows and impact screens. While both are designed to shield your home during a storm, they work in different ways and offer distinct advantages depending on your goals, budget, and lifestyle.

In this article, we’ll break down the differences between these two hurricane defense systems, helping you choose the best fit for your home in Brevard or Indian River County.

What Are Impact Windows?

Impact windows are specialized, permanently installed windows constructed with multiple layers of laminated glass. They’re engineered to withstand high-speed impacts and resist shattering, much like a car windshield.

Key Benefits:

• Permanent Protection – No need to install or deploy anything before a storm.
• Energy Efficiency – These windows can improve insulation and reduce energy bills.
• Sound Dampening – The thick glass layers block outside noise.
• UV Protection – Most impact windows filter UV rays, protecting your furniture and floors.

Considerations:

• Cost – Impact windows are expensive, especially for large homes or homes with many windows.
• Installation Time – Replacing all windows takes time and usually requires permitting and inspections.
• Limited Flexibility – Once installed, there’s no way to temporarily remove or open up the window space beyond what the standard opening allows.

What Are Impact Screens?

Impact screens—also known as hurricane screens or motorized impact screens—are a flexible, retractable solution made of tightly woven, high-strength synthetic fabric. They’re typically installed over large openings like patios, lanais, or garages and can be deployed with the push of a button.

Lafferty Hurricane Protection specializes in motorized impact screens for outdoor living spaces. These aren’t your average bug screens—they're engineered to block flying debris and withstand wind speeds that mimic a Category 5 hurricane.

Key Benefits:

• Retractable Convenience – Roll them up when not in use for an unobstructed view and fresh air.
• Versatile Coverage – Perfect for large outdoor areas like patios, pool cages, and garage openings.
• Cost-Effective for Large Spaces – Significantly cheaper than installing impact windows in a whole patio enclosure.
• Ventilation & Visibility – Screens allow airflow and light, even when deployed.

Considerations:

• Not a Replacement for Windows – Impact screens don’t protect individual windows or glass doors.
• Power Dependency – Motorized versions require electricity, though many have manual overrides or battery backups.
• Not Designed for Year-Round Insulation – Unlike impact windows, screens don’t offer temperature control benefits.

Head-to-Head Comparison

Which Option Is Right for You?

The answer depends on how your home is structured and what areas you’re trying to protect.

💡 Choose Impact Windows If:

• You're doing a full home remodel or window replacement.
• You want year-round energy savings and noise reduction.
• Your budget allows for a permanent, high-end solution.
• You're looking for a one-time, set-it-and-forget-it approach.

💡 Choose Impact Screens If:

• You want to protect outdoor living spaces like patios, garages, or pool areas.
• You prefer a flexible, retractable solution.
• You're looking for a lower-cost way to protect large openings.
• You already have solid windows but need additional protection elsewhere.

Many of our customers actually use both—impact windows for the main structure and impact screens for extended living spaces.

Real-Life Scenarios in Brevard & Indian River County

At Lafferty Hurricane Protection, we’ve seen a range of needs across our service area:

• In Viera, FL: Homeowners with newer homes often opt for impact screens on their covered lanais and patios, preserving their backyard views while ensuring storm readiness.
• In Melbourne Beach: Older homes benefit from impact window upgrades during renovations to boost resale value and reduce insurance premiums.
• In Sebastian and Palm Bay: Many customers use motorized impact screens on garages so they can safely use their space as a workout room or workshop, even during storm season.

What About Insurance Discounts?

Both impact windows and hurricane-rated screens can make you eligible for insurance discounts under Florida’s wind mitigation inspection program. Insurance companies reward homeowners who invest in products that meet or exceed state wind resistance standards.

Our products are Florida Building Code compliant and professionally installed, so you’ll be set up to take advantage of any eligible savings.

Why Work With Lafferty Hurricane Protection?

We’re more than just installers—we’re a local partner in your home’s defense system. Whether you're looking for motorized impact screens, accordion shutters, or expert insight into the best hurricane protection strategy for your property, our team is here to help.

• ✔️ No subcontractors—all in-house, trained technicians
• ✔️ Customized solutions for homes across Brevard and Indian River County
• ✔️ Licensed and insured with 30+ years of experience
• ✔️ 1-year workmanship warranty and 3-year structural warranty

We’ll evaluate your space, offer honest recommendations, and ensure every install meets the strictest safety standards.

Final Thoughts

When it comes to impact windows vs. impact screens, there’s no one-size-fits-all answer. Instead, the best choice depends on how you use your space, your long-term goals, and your budget.

The good news? You don’t have to decide alone. At Lafferty Hurricane Protection, we’ll walk you through the pros and cons and help design a hurricane protection system that works for your lifestyle.